In
1973, the Grateful Dead started playing more spacy, graceful transitions
between songs. This had not been a big feature of their music in the previous
years – there are not many such cases in 1972, for instance, when the Dead’s
segues tended to hop straight from one song into another. Spacy transitions
weren’t new to the Dead, of course: back in the sixties they were common
features in, say, the Other One>New Potato Caboose suites of ’68, or
Mountains of the Moon>Dark Star in ‘69. But as the Dead added more songs to
their repertoire and phased out the Cryptical ending jam, spaciness retreated
to the internal portions of Dark Star or the Other One, and spacy transition
jams were rarely played from 1970-72.
Some
songs were built for transitions: China>Rider was a regular link (though
usually not jammed out very much at the time); Truckin’ in 1972 frequently
headed down the road to an Other One; and He’s Gone steadily expanded in fall
’72, swelling into a giant end jam that would kick off an extended suite. But
these usually weren’t very spacy jams, being built on steady grooves (though
there are some Truckin’>Other One jams from the Europe tour that became
their own meandering voyages). It just wasn’t that common in ’72 for the Dead
to float gently from song to song.
There
are still some rare moments in 1972 where the Dead would enter quiet reflective
spaces between songs:
5/25/72 Uncle John’s
Band>Wharf Rat
A
lovely little glide where they spend almost 2 minutes contemplating
possibilities before settling on Wharf Rat.
7/18/72 Truckin’>Dark
Star
The
last 90 seconds of Truckin’ are like a gently bubbling stew in which the Dead
float placidly until Dark Star kicks off.
8/21/72 El
Paso>space>Deal
Some
quick tuning turns into a 3-minute lonesome space, mostly a Garcia/Lesh duet
with volume swells and a wistful bass melody, until Garcia hops into Deal. (This
is like a quiet continuation of Dark Star that got stranded outside of El Paso.)
Sometimes
in 1972 the Dead would use a unique melodic jam as a transition – for instance,
the three-minute Caution>Uncle John’s
Band jam on 3/22/72, where a beautiful and seemingly composed melody
appears from nowhere and then vanishes again:
Some
more examples of this type of jam are here:
You
might think Dark Star would have lots of spacy transitions, being designed for
open-ended journeys to space and beyond. Once the second verse was dropped, all
kinds of songs could find themselves emerging from the distant galactic
reaches. But in 1972, Dark Star segues tended not to be distinct transition
jams per se, but rather sudden shifts to a different dimension. Most typically
Dark Star would wind up in a big Tiger freakout or a post-meltdown swirl, and
once the noise subsided the next song would rise out of the ashes – think of
how Sugar Magnolia appears on 4/14 or 4/17, or El Paso on 8/27. But other times
the Dead would be jamming along and a new song would just be dropped abruptly
into the proceedings, making a quick juxtaposition – for instance China Cat or
Cumberland Blues on 9/24 & 9/27. So there usually wasn’t a prolonged in-between
passage bridging Dark Star and another song; it was more often like a swift
jump out the exit hatch.
But
sometimes the Dead would prepare for the next song with a quiet transitional glide
out of Dark Star:
5/11/72 Dark
Star>Sugar Magnolia
At
the end of Dark Star (after an abandoned Truckin’ tease, some hasty Garcia
tuning, and a Bird Song quote from Lesh) they drift into a nice gentle 2-minute
guitar-trio interlude before Sugar Magnolia begins.
8/24/72 Dark
Star>Morning Dew
Dark
Star fades in the last 90 seconds to a quiet elegant passage with volume swells
and wisps of feedback, until Morning Dew rudely intrudes.
9/16/72 Dark
Star>Brokedown Palace
The
Dead slow down after a fast jam and the last minute of Dark Star becomes a very
pretty prelude to Brokedown Palace.
12/15/72 Dark
Star>Morning Dew
After
the obligatory Tiger jam, the music calms and the last minute of Dark Star is a
rather eerie, melancholy glide towards Morning Dew.
Of
course I can’t go without mentioning the unique ending of the 10/23/72 Dark Star – following a fierce
Tiger & feedback, the final 3 minutes find the Dead transformed into a
haunted orchestra playing a tune of dignified sadness. John Hilgart calls it
“arguably the greatest example of…Dead ‘chamber music.’ Suddenly the band is a
string trio, it sounds like they are bowing their instruments, and the piece
they are playing is moody and gorgeous.” One of the most beautiful endings of
any Dark Star.
As
for the Other One, in 1972 it was almost always played with both verses and the
conclusion, and the Dead tended to go abruptly from the closing lick to the
next tune without much drift. The Other One, like Dark Star, could have any
number of spacy passages within its jams, but unlike Dark Star its ending
remained a stable destination in 1972, so it’s rare to find extended
transitions out of the Other One that year. One fine exception starts the year
with the 12/31/71 jam>Black Peter
– Garcia’s starting Black Peter as the Other One ends, but they have to stop
for some tuning, so instead they melt into a sweet little pretty jam for 2
minutes before Black Peter restarts.
Sometimes
we find great internal transitions in the Other One sandwiches – for instance,
the Other One>He’s Gone>Other One
on 10/24/72, where He’s Gone is preceded by a nearly 2-minute spacy passage
of spiky delicacy, almost sounding like they’re trying to reprise the piece
from the Dark Star the night before.
(Other
transitional highlights from the Other One sandwiches of ’72 include the
lead-ups to El Paso on 4/7, Me & Bobby McGee on 5/10, and Black Peter on 8/12.)
But
the Other One wasn’t invariably played with its ending in ’72. The 9/26/72 Other One, for instance, has just one verse (missing on the SBD tape due to a reel flip). After the Tiger, the
last two & a half minutes are another evocative space, Lesh plucking loudly
over Garcia’s wistful notes until they land in an unexpected Baby Blue.
On
10/27/72, the Dead skip the second
verse again in a laid-back Other One, and the last minute is a pretty but foreboding
transitional bridge (peppered by audience screams) that ends up in an
incongruous Mississippi Half-Step.
The
Dead ended the year on 12/31/72 with
another incomplete but magnificent Other One. After the first and only verse,
they drop right into a lovely soothing slow piece with David Crosby. Full of
Garcia sweetness, it sounds composed, but I don’t think it was ever heard
again. Once it reaches a conclusion, the last 45 seconds are a heavenly
volume-swelled bridge to Morning Dew.
In
1973 the Dead started leaving out the second verse of the Other One in many
versions – out of 22 Other Ones that year, I think the second verse only
appeared in 6 of them. This opened up more possibilities for the Dead to jam
their way into the next song like they did in Dark Star. Sometimes a song would
pop right out of some Other One jamming without much of a transition. But often
the Other One ended with noisy Tigers or blasts of Feedback, then a new song
would timidly creep forth – 12/19/73 would be a classic example of this – so the
Other One doesn’t appear very often on this list.
What
I was looking for in 1973 were distinctive or unusual spacy transitions between
songs (not the spaces within longer jams) – I call these Transitive Spaces. The
Dead took an increasingly “floaty” approach in 1973 with new jam suites and
more varied song segues, often making pillowy clouds for 20 or 30 seconds at
the end of one song to clear the way for the next. True, most segues were still
quick jump-cuts or sudden shifts; but I focus here on the transitional spaces
at least a minute or two long that became interesting pieces of music in their
own right. (Admittedly some of these transitive spaces are not much different
from spacy passages in the middle of an Other One, except for where they’re
located!)
2/15/73 Dark
Star>Eyes of the World
Lesh
takes a big bass solo after the verse in Dark Star, playing with his quad
system (each string going to different speakers), and the solo’s more bouncy
and tuneful than usual for him. In the final minute, Garcia joins him for a
short but sparkling duet, creating a sunny melody before Lesh nudges them into
Eyes. This isn’t a spacy transition, but is one of the brightest and most
memorable of the year.
2/21/73 Truckin’>Eyes
of the World, Eyes>Stella Blue
Near
the end of Truckin’, the band starts to dive into Eyes of the World without
Garcia, but evidently change their minds and call it off. When Garcia returns
in the final minute of Truckin’, suddenly they enter an intimate little space
of sweetness & bliss, Garcia & Lesh coupled in harmony. With that out
of the way, they start Eyes for real.
Then
in the last two minutes of Eyes, the jam ends and they slide into another
space, this one not so melodic, mostly guitars & piano drifting aimlessly
while Lesh makes noises. Lesh rounds it out with some conclusive chords before
Garcia makes a very awkward switch to Stella Blue.
2/24/73 –
Truckin’>Eyes of the World, Eyes>Sugar Magnolia
This
murky audience tape had largely vanished for two decades and was little-heard
until it resurfaced again a few years ago, revealing its treasures. A hot
Truckin’ jam starts heading in the Other One direction, but the Dead change
course with a drumroll at 10:30, the main jam fading into a magical Garcia/Lesh
duet. For two minutes they’re coupled in a sonata of piercing beauty, clouds
parting to the music of the angels. At the end, a sudden burst of feedback
announces Eyes of the World like the cold world breaking in on a heavenly dream.
But
the show’s surprises aren’t over. Eyes wraps up with an excited finish by 9:30,
then Garcia takes off in another solo space (interrupted by a tapecut and the
taper confidently announcing “the Other One!”). When Lesh joins in, that indeed
sounds like their destination and there’s a little Other One duet accompanied
by drums. (Here’s where the available SBD tape cuts in, after 11:20.) But they
veer away from the Other One, Garcia drops out, and Lesh starts another cheerful
bass solo, backed by drums at first but then on his own, banging out chords in
quad stereo. He invites the others back in, and they join him in a happy
rhythmic groove that soon turns into a Feelin’ Groovy jam. Once that ends, they’re
not sure what’s next and stumble around for a couple minutes trying to rekindle
the momentum, Godchaux not quite in sync with Garcia. Lesh lays down some
closing chords and they drift into a pretty space which only lasts briefly
before Weir strikes up Sugar Magnolia.
https://archive.org/details/gd73-02-24.sbd.elliot.11929.sbeok.shnf
(mislabeled SBD fragment - it’s the
post-Eyes jam)
Nothing
else quite compares to the duet at the end of Truckin’ – this post covers many
other beautiful pieces throughout 1973, but for me it doesn’t have an equal.
There are similar moments from the period though: the space at the end of
Truckin’ on 2/21 is in much the same vein (though briefer). There’s also a
short spot in the post-verse space of Dark Star on 2/22/73 (after 10:45) where
Garcia & Lesh are in the same kind of brooding place for a minute before a
snarling Tiger approaches. (You can even go back to the end of the 5/10/72
Other One for a short but strikingly close passage.)
As
for the Feelin’ Groovy jam, at the time it was usually an internal Dark Star
jam but hadn’t been played since November ’72. It had made one appearance as a
transitional jam outside Dark Star, on 10/2/72
where it followed Truckin’ in a unique joyful jam leading up to a chiming space
& Morning Dew (you can hear the family resemblance to 2/24/73’s Eyes jam,
though the ’72 jam is a bit more giddy & sloppy).
In
March ’73 the Feelin’ Groovy jam would be absorbed into the China>Rider
transition, but it would take a surprising turn in the 3/31/73 Other One, where it follows a long wah space, substitutes
for the return to the Other One theme, and serves as an impromptu bridge to
(where else) I Know You Rider. Not a spacy transition at all, but one of the
most unique endings of any Other One, like the Dead suddenly skipped a song.
(The
3/24/73 Truckin’ jam could be
considered a marginal case on this list – the Dead go into a quiet drift once
the proper Truckin’ jam is through, and later pass through several minutes of
underwater wah warbling before the Dark Star verse, so those are spacy
transition points – but it could also be regarded as one long jam moving
through different phases. Personally I consider the pre-Dark Star space to be
part of an inverted Dark Star.)
3/26/73
Truckin’>Weather Report Suite Prelude
Garcia
unusually takes up the slide in the Truckin’ jam for a bluesy touch (an
occasional habit of his in early ’73), then they flirt with the Other One for a
bit; but in the last two & a half minutes they suddenly slow down into a
quiet, pretty introspective space – mostly Garcia & piano with a bit of
Weir backing. Weir brings up the Prelude he’s been kicking around, and they use
that as the jumping-off point to a longer mellow jam. This is nice but never
takes off; finally in the last minute Garcia twirls into a sweet Wharf Rat
prelude before starting the song.
(Weir’s
Prelude was played a few times in early ’73 – on 3/21 and 3/28 it’s used as a
prelude to Dark Star, and on 4/2 it serves to introduce Eyes of the World. The
Prelude had also appeared earlier as one of a series of jams within the
11/19/72 Dark Star; but it wouldn’t find a home until being attached to the
Weather Report Suite in September ’73.)
3/30/73 Truckin’>Eyes
of the World
A
meandering slide jam in Truckin’ turns into a more uptempo jazzy groove; but
then the Dead seem to run out of direction and sputter out. The next two
minutes are mostly Godchaux tinkling on the piano pretty much by himself with
just some quiet noodling from the guitarists, until Eyes arrives. Not very
interesting.
(The
4/2/73 Here Comes Sunshine jam is
another marginal entry here. Although this is almost the only Here Comes
Sunshine with a transition jam, it’s more like a typical 10-minute Other One
jam stuck onto the end of Sunshine, climaxing with the ever-present Tiger. The
last minute does get into some spacy swoops before Bobby McGee, though.)
5/26/73 Other
One>Eyes of the World
In
the wake of the Tiger, the Dead relax for a final couple minutes of subdued wah
beauty, the band keeping up a busy patter while Garcia plays his lonesome
keens. (The 5/13/73 Other One takes
a very similar course in the Tiger aftermath at the end, but is a little edgier
and not as relaxed.)
6/9/73
Truckin’>Playing in the Band
After
the drums & bass section in Truckin’, the band embarks on a luscious
4-minute voyage to unmapped inner realms. At first the jam centers on the quad
bass, cymbals, Weir’s phased harmonics & strums, and then becomes a
delicate wah tapestry. In the last minute after Garcia’s brief Here Comes
Sunshine tease, they seem to be forming a stately new melody on the spot; but
Garcia’s in a hurry to move on to Playing in the Band and keeps pushing the
opening lick until the others join him. But they could have stayed in this dreamy
space…
https://archive.org/details/gd1973-06-09.120958.barry.smith.AUD-fob.flac1644/gd73-06-09d2t05.flac
(AUD: there’s a cut at the start of this
section around 8:30, but the sound is phenomenal – for otherworldly beauty, this
is as good as it gets)
7/1/73 Other
One>Wharf Rat
Once
the last growls of the Tiger subside, the Dead quietly hover in a peaceful
still ocean for a glorious 2 minutes before Wharf Rat arrives. A wonderful
passage.
7/28/73 Truckin’>El
Paso
A
typical Nobody’s Fault jam closes Truckin’, but rather than a straight segue to
El Paso they take a 2-minute detour into a quiet, spacy Garcia/Lesh duet.
9/15/73 Let It
Grow>Stella Blue
After
a hectic Let It Grow jam, the Dead drop into 3 minutes of quiet warbling with
hushed wah & Rhodes touches, setting the stage for Stella Blue. (The next
Let It Grow>Stella segue on 9/17 is a more sudden shift. Only a few Let It
Grows from fall ‘73 would segue into other tunes.)
9/26/73 Truckin’>Eyes
of the World
Truckin’
unwinds into a jazzy drums/bass/piano segment, but then in the final minute the
mood shifts, the band hushes, and Garcia & Lesh reach a place of unexpected
beauty, very reminiscent of 2/24/73.
10/23/73 Other
One>Weather Report Suite
After
the verse, the short Other One quickly peters out for a drum solo. The band
comes back with a flurry and a calmer direction – Garcia’s playing with a slide
now, and with Godchaux’s shimmering Rhodes and Lesh’s soft bass pings, they
sail into 4 minutes of beautiful melancholy. One of the year’s high points.
10/30/73 Eyes of the
World>Weather Report Suite
Most
Eyes come to quick ends, but here for over a minute the Dead drift leisurely on
a mellow sea in an unusually relaxed ending, until an impatient Weir jumps into
his Prelude.
You
may have noticed few post-Eyes of the World jams on this list since February
’73. Once the song’s jam structure solidified, Eyes rarely opened up to
spaciness at the end. Usually, Garcia would put on the brakes and slow it down
so there would be at most a quick 15 or 20-second glide to the next song, not a
prolonged transition. So Eyes of the World doesn’t have many distinctive segues
this year.
One
exception is the 12/4/73 Eyes which
basically substitutes for the Other One as the big second-set freakout in that
shortened show – when Eyes itself comes to an end around 13:30, they dive
straight into noisy weirdness, a long buzzing space, powerful feedback drones,
and a skittering near-Tiger at the end. (Lesh unfortunately drops out for the
last few minutes.) It’s kind of a test run for the 12/6/73 Dark Star – not very
pretty, but unique for an Eyes.
(I
should also mention one earlier oddity, the 6/10/73 Eyes where in the last 40
seconds, the Dead seamlessly switch to playing an impromptu little blues jam.
It only lasts half a minute before they drop it for Stella Blue, but it
foreshadows some ’74 moments like the 6/18/74 It’s A Sin jam.)
The
Dead started playing the Mind Left Body jam regularly in fall ’73. At the time
it mainly appeared within Dark Star and didn’t usually connect straight to
other tunes, unlike in ’74, so I won’t say much about it here (it has its own post anyway). For instance the famous 12/2/73 version in Playing in the Band is
followed by a 2-minute choppy, upbeat jam before they segue to He’s Gone. But I’ll
point out the 11/20/73 Other One,
where Weir introduces the theme at the end and the Dead go through a few
hurried passes, then Garcia steers them through a brief simple melody to Stella
Blue.
Other
late-’73 deep-space Other Ones with fine endings:
11/23/73 Other One>Me
& Bobby McGee
After
exploring the depths of Feedback, in the last minute Garcia & the others
peer back into the sunlight with a brief Bach-like interlude that coasts into
Bobby McGee.
12/8/73 Other
One>Wharf Rat
An
even deeper dive into Feedback fades to a final minute of drone-haunted beauty.
Wharf Rat comes too soon.
Meanwhile,
it was still common for Dark Stars in 1973 to end with Tigers or Feedback
episodes, but an increasing number of Dark Stars also ended on a gentler spacy
note, providing the audience a little cushion before the next tune. Some of the
best examples of these include:
3/28/73 – after a demented
Slipknot-type section, the Dead quiet down with a minute of calming wah glitter
before starting Eyes.
10/19/73 – following a frantic
Tiger, the Dead float quietly on soothing volume swells for a minute before
Morning Dew.
11/11/73 – after the rousing
Mind Left Body jam finishes, the Dead glide prettily towards Eyes.
11/30/73 – the Dark Star jam
ends with 2 minutes of a jazzily abstract Garcia/Weir duet.
12/18/73 – as the Feedback
settles, Garcia & Weir weave some gently enchanting arpeggios and craft a
final closing melody for the last Dark Star of the year…then they step aside
for a drum solo!
I’ll stop there and leave 1974 for another day… Be sure to comment if there are some tasty transition jams I’ve overlooked!
Sorry for the delay in posting! The last month was a whirlwind... But here are some soothing '73 sounds for the weary traveler.
ReplyDeleteGood grief! Now we know what you've been doing these last months. There's so much detail there, I'll have to go back again and listen to all the transitions as I go through it. Excellent breakdown of 1973.
ReplyDeleteJust one thing I noticed as I read it. You write "(Other transitional highlights from the Other One sandwiches of ’72 include the lead-ups to Me & My Uncle on 4/7, Me & Bobby McGee on 5/10, and Black Peter on 8/12.)"...... On 4/7 they went into El Paso not Me & My Uncle (I know, I was there). Great stuff, LIA.
Oops, thanks for the correction! Fixed it.
Deletenew here. great stuff. thx.
ReplyDeleteNew Here? There is such a lot of great research and reading on this site. Have a good look round.
DeleteNo doubt the Dead were already pioneers in (and masters of) electronic psychedelic music before 1972 but I’ve always wondered if their European travels truly exposed them to the spacey/cosmic sounds that were simultaneously blossoming there (and had been blossoming for a few years, at least). For instance, that beautiful segue into Playin’ on 6/9/73 would sound perfectly “normal” at a Pink Floyd, Gong or Ash Ra Tempel concert from around the same period (or a couple years earlier). If they weren’t much aware of the krautrock and “space rock” scene before their 72 tour, they must surely have been made aware of it on that tour through their interactions with fans, promoters etc.
ReplyDeleteI wonder. The Dead never mentioned their European counterparts, and I suspect those bands had little or no influence on the Dead. But some members of the Dead did attend a Pink Floyd show in March 1973, so there was at least some curiosity...
DeleteWeir (with Ratdog) did Mathilda Mother from PF's 1967 debut album so maybe he/they knew their early stuff?
DeleteLIA, I'm very curious about that. Are there more details of when/where they saw them, or which members? It seems if someone knew they saw them, then there would have to have been some expression of the experience they had. Or is that the extant of what's known? To me at least, a very mind blistering question. Thanks for all the research you do!
DeleteThe account came via the late Harvey Lubar, who said that he & Jerry Moore sat near Garcia, Lesh, & Owsley at Floyd's show in quad at Radio City in March '73, when the Dead had the night off, & that the Dead contingent left at set break (ie. before Dark Side).
DeleteActually, I have a different source! An old deadhead following them on tour in March '73 wrote:
Delete"On the day off between shows at Nassau Coliseum I had the insane luck of not only seeing Pink Floyd at Radio City Music Hall, but to actually snag an empty end seat in the Orchestra next to Keith. The entire band was there, except for Jerry... When I asked Keith where Jerry was, he said he took off that morning to see some friends."
Now, this guy's memory of which Dead members attended is totally different than Harvey Lubar's, so I don't know what to make of that. All he remembered talking to Keith about was the upcoming Dead shows! ("Keith asked me if I planned to attend any other Dead shows that tour... He made an animated point to tell me Boston was going be great; that they were all looking forward to blowing it out that night as it was the last show on the tour.")
Per one comment on an audience tape of Pink Floyd's show: "The Grateful Dead were in attendance at this concert; you can hear someone near one of the tapers saying, 'The Dead just left.'" (I think this happens after Careful with that Axe.)
I don't know what anybody in the Dead thought about Pink Floyd - maybe they just came to check out the quad sound system. I guess all we can conclude is that Garcia either wasn't interested in seeing Floyd or didn't want to sit through a whole show! Maybe the band's attitude was more professional curiosity than enthusiasm.
Re. Grateful Dead interest in European psych/space rock, there's a 1980 Relix interview where Jerry said he liked Pink Floyd in response to a question about whether he listened to the radio: “Just the stuff that hit everybody. I like ‘The Wall’ a lot. Everybody likes that.” Apparently Syd Barrett's girlfriend watched the moon landing at Jerry Garcia's house with members of the Grateful Dead? Walter Funk aka Altered Walter, who performed and recorded with Daevid Allen, gave Jerry Garcia a CD of Angel's Egg at some point around the early 1990s; it's unknown whether Jerry listened to it (hope he did) but at least we know cross-pollination was attempted.
DeleteThat's true, Jenny Spires had been Syd Barrett's girlfriend through the early Pink Floyd days. Apparently she met Rock Scully or some of the Dead's associates in London which was how she got connected to the Dead; friends invited her on a trip to the US and in summer '69 she was traveling through the country, going to Woodstock, visiting the Dead...and watching the moon landing with Garcia.
Delete"I’m not sure why I happened to be at his place that day. It had been my birthday a couple of days before and I was on my way up to Oregon and stayed over there on my way. Jerry was a very generous host but he was quiet, really... I can’t really remember having any real meaningful or deep conversation with him. It was just very relaxed with just a few of us sitting around with food and wowing out on the moon landing."
https://www.jambase.com/article/jerry-garcia-moon-landing-pink-floyd-syd-barrett-girlfriend
https://www.eyeplug.net/magazine/in-conversation-with-jenny-spires-by-michelle-coomber/
Quite a coincidence, but it wasn't really a musical connection...
I forgot Garcia said he liked "The Wall" in 1980 (along with Elvis Costello & Dire Straits)! By then Pink Floyd were rather far removed from the kind of space-rock they were doing in the early '70s.
The 1972-09-26 Other One does have the first verse followed by a bass solo, it is missing on the SBD because of a reel change but is present on the AUD starting at 23:49 here
ReplyDeletehttps://archive.org/details/gd1972-09-26.partial-sbd-patched.powell-ladner.25281.shnf
Egads, I should have caught that! Fixed.
DeleteI was recently talking about this topic of when fleshed out transitions began, though I began with talking about some of their weirder Spring/Summer 1969 transition attempts. Especially 5/24/69 and that brief era when they seemed to be determined to make a suite involving He Was a Friend (I refuse to use the suggested "Hand to Hold" title), DTRag, and Chinacat. Sometimes those worked pretty good but my point about them was that they weren't "pretty" transitions, they were more cocky "let's see if we can pull this off and make it work" transitions. They were taking songs that didn't flow together and forcing them to.
ReplyDeleteWhile often fun, it didn't really begin to work until they started taking their time. This is a great breakdown of those moments, I've heard all these shows a bunch but there are a few moments listed here that I don't remember offhand and look forward to paying closer attention to. But I definitely know 2/24 well and fully agree on it being a top notch example of this 1973 phenomenon. I've always said if not for the missing reels that one would have been an official release 20 years ago.
Though I personally feel the seeds were a bit earlier than 72, in the 1971 Other Ones with the Uncles inside, which evolved a bit in the Fall to include other cowboy tunes as well. Yes they were more of the earlier and more abrupt kind of transitions you described well and not these type of dreamy 73 transitions, but I think Fall 71 is where they started getting the idea. But since they simplified things a bit that Fall for Keith they weren't a band ready to leave too many of those open spaces yet. And despite the far out jam sequences in Europe they also seemed to try to stick to a formula and maintain a little professional consistency for the foreign audiences they made a real effort to win over. It wasn't until late 1972 when they could relax a bit.
I didn't really dive back into 1971 here, but one interesting thing about those Other One>Me & My Uncle suites of '71: when they started doing those in August '71, they'd dissolve into a quiet spacy goo after Me & My Uncle. But in fall '71, they changed their approach and instead jumped right back into the Other One rhythm. Me & My Uncle itself would always abruptly materialize from nowhere mid-jam, so in general it didn't really lend itself to distinctive transition jams. (If you simply snipped Uncle out of most of these suites, you'd never notice it was missing.)
DeleteAfter the mid-1969 "let's make a suite out of anything" heyday, they did play around with song suites a few times in summer 1970. (The Other One suites on 7/10 & 7/11 have abrupt switches, but the Dark Stars on 6/24 and 11/8/70 have some of their best-ever transitions.) But they started exploring the idea more often in August '71 with the interrupted Other Ones (before Keith arrived), and in fall '71 they started doing more Dark Star sandwiches as well, though these were never frequent. The fall '71 jams in general were more hurried than they would be by 1973, racing from one idea to another.
BTW - Technically "Just a Hand to Hold" is the correct title for the Dead's "Friend of Mine!" But like you, I can't bring myself to call it that. (After all, the Dead dropped the verses about a hand to hold, so they don't sing that part.) Though it's a little shady that the Dead's releases, as far as I know, don't give Mark Spoelstra any credit for his song.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uQM_gm6YZuA
I haven't had any time to write these last two months, so the next post will be in early July. Sorry about the long wait!
ReplyDelete